PA-08 Becomes Third “Toss-Up” Congressional Race In Commonwealth This Cycle
Yes, Pennsylvania truly is “America’s Swing State.”
Every four years, the eyes of the nation turn to William Penn’s creation for how 9.2 million registered voters will cast their ballot for the presidency.
And every even-numbered year, the eyes of the political elite turn to the Commonwealth to see how a smaller subsection of those residents will cast their vote for Congress.
In 2026, control of the U.S. House of Representatives could be determined by 3-4 seats in Pennsylvania alone. And now three of those four contests are in the “toss-up” category.
On Thursday morning, “Sabato’s Crystal Ball” from the Center for Politics at the University of Virginia moved the 8th Congressional District contest in the state from “Leans Republican” to “Toss-Up,” showing how tight the race has become between incumbent Republican Rob Bresnahan and Democratic challenger Paige Cognetti.
Kyle Kondik, managing editor of the Crystal Ball, said that while Bresnahan “occupies a reddening northeast Pennsylvania seat that backed Trump by 8.5 points in 2024,” the race is “better described” as a toss-up.
Cognetti, the mayor of Scranton, outraised the freshmen congressman in Q2, pulling in $1.5 million compared to Bresnahan’s $715,000.
With Sabato’s shift, all three race raters, including The Cook Political Report and Inside Elections, moved the race into the “Toss Up” category. In their update, Inside Elections cited Bresnahan’s “finances” and “health care issues,” while Cook Political Report noted Bresnahan’s “self-inflicted” wounds, including his “stock trades [that] have dogged him all cycle,” and Cognetti’s unique “political brand,” running for mayor as an independent in 2019 to take on the corrupt Democratic machine in Scranton.
A June poll by Lake Research Partners and sponsored by the Democratic-sponsored House Majority PAC (HMP) gave Cognetti a 2-point advantage, though the survey did not indicate a margin of error.
The contests in the Lehigh Valley and the state’s Capitol Region also fall into the toss-up category.
In the 7th Congressional District, incumbent Rep. Ryan Mackenzie is in a tough battle with union leader Bob Brooks. The challenger has been endorsed by such prominent Democrats as House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries and Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro, to name two. Brooks doubled up Mackenzie in Q2 fundraising, bringing in a haul of $1.2 million to $631,000 for the freshman representative.
The HMP sponsored a survey that had Brooks +4 in late June.
And in the 10th Congressional District, it’s a rematch of the 2024 contest between Republican Scott Perry and Democrat Janelle Stelson. Perry defeated Stelson by 5,100 votes, but it appears that the former broadcast journalist has learned from her defeat, outraising the seven-term congressman by more than 2-to-1 last quarter. She brought in $1.67 million to her campaign, while Perry raised $780,000.
The other Pennsylvania race to be listed by those who “rate races” is in the 1st Congressional District, as Republican Brian Fitzpatrick looks for a return trip to Washington against Democratic opponent Bob Harvie. Sabato and Inside Elections place the contest in the “Leans Republican” category, while Cook slots it in as “Likely Republican.”